Wednesday, July 28, 2010

MoreMarin Buzz Home: Tam High reunion invitation brouhaha

« SubUrban Legend - The day of the locust | Main | Video of the Day - Doga »

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Tam High reunion invitation brouhaha

An invitation to a local high school reunion has caused the fur to fly in Marin.

(Click to enlarge)

The invite for a class reunion for Tamalpais High School class of 1980, contains images that are offensive-- or at the very least-- insensitive. The invitation in question has a graphic of the now-banned former school name and mascot, the Tamalpais High Indians. In addition, an old image of a flirty Indian maid is also pictured. The mascot was changed to the Red Tailed Hawks in 1990.

The Pacific Sun's Nikki Silverstein mentioned the invite in her Hero and Zero column chastising the senders of the invitation for their insensitivity to Native Americans.

But it didn't end there.

What followed were a torrent of commenters on the Pacific Sun website slamming Silverstein for being too PC in her condemnation. A sample of some of the comments--

"Wow! When did Ms. Silverstein become the annointed moral barometer for Marin?"
  • "We were the TAMALPAIS INDIANS you and your PC NAZIS, yes nazis, can't change that and if you weren't a TAM INDIAN, why do you care"
  • "Dear Ms. Silverstein, what is wrong with the country quite frankly is...YOU! You and all the crones that harbor this politically correct agenda that is primarily designed to control people."

    Several commenters defend Ms. Silverstein, but they seem to be far fewer. We agree with the detractors in that it's one thing to use the images in a historical context; it's quite another to use them for marketing purposes. But what is really upsetting, are the vitriolic comments aimed at Silverstein.

    The story is beginning to make its way into the blogosphere. The reunion takes place at the end of August which means there is enough time for it to really heat up.

    Posted by Pam Gould at 10:55 AM in Mill Valley, What's With That?! | Permalink

    Comments

    Tonyboysf

    GO Indians! Schools - probably their coaches picked original team names I guess, and I doubt any were ever chosen to degrade
    or defame the people who's images were used.
    To the contrary, warriors, and indians and
    fierce animals were chosen to instill a spire of respect, dignity, and even admiration for the culture of ancients and native peoples. The fact that a few indians
    or others are personally offended by teams
    using their names is really unfortunate. I think they would be happier with a more positive attitude! Posted by a old Woodrow
    Wilson HS, Warrior(Greek style)70'


    Posted by: Tonyboysf | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 12:31 PM

    Tam Indian

    Go Indians! Class of '85.

    Thinking I'll attend this reunion to honor our mascott.

    Posted by: Tam Indian | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 12:38 PM

    icarus13

    Yeah, enough of this crap. Let's get down to a real politics of change. Give money to a land trust, volunteer to help others, work on a campaign to balance city and county budgets, serve your darn jury duty. This endless cultural politics is tiresome.

    Posted by: icarus13 | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 12:42 PM

    An Indian From The Class of 1980

    Additionally: Go (Fremont High School, S'vale) Indians!

    Screw PCism!

    Fremont Firebirds ... sheesh! What a joke.

    Posted by: An Indian From The Class of 1980 | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 12:50 PM

    m

    LOLZ - Are they gonna open up a Casino Night and sell discount cigs? Get Lives people! Where's the outrage over Obambi and Boosh letting the Mexi's over the border like it ain't even there?

    Posted by: m | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 12:52 PM

    In God we Trust

    This non-substantive PC crap is getting old. Focus on substantive issues like the economy, the quality of the educations our children are receiving, and the cost of government.

    Posted by: In God we Trust | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 12:53 PM

    DPendragon

    Pekin High School in 1980 changed their mascot from the Pekin Chinks to the Pekin Dragons.

    If people can only understand that with the naming of a mascot by using only certain ethnic groups, demeans the people as non-human.

    http://wheelingpds.blogspot.com/2008/09/racist-mascots.html

    Posted by: DPendragon | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 01:11 PM

    SFDoug

    Clearly the commenters above have never been on the other side of a stereotype or discrimination. This isn't just some "PC crap." Harmful stereotypes continue to be taught in schools and homes throughout the country, and this has real consequence to people like me.

    First off, I am not saying that we should act as if the "Indian" never was the Tam High mascot. The problem is specifically the way the mascot is depicted (on a "Wanted" poster.)

    But the defenders really have me concerned. You could use the same rationale to support celebrating other "charming traditions" -- like the one at my high school where African-Americans had an "exclusive" seating area at lunch and on the football bench (they were kept off the field.) Or the tradition of a publicly funded organization in my former east coast community that blocked any minorities from applying for membership, in honor of their town's history of KKK activity.

    The way the Indian mascot is shown on the Tam High reunion flyer perpetuates such harm. I had hoped that at least in Marin we had evolved enough to recognize that such stereotypes are part of our history, not our present.

    Posted by: SFDoug | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 01:15 PM

    Mike

    You can't re-write history. This is what the team was called, and no amount of touchy-feely PC "sensitivity" can change that. Nikki, shut up! Teams use powerful images for their team names. Naming a team "Indians" was an homage to Indians, who most people I know would consider to be brave and resourceful and tough. It's like the Fighting Irish or the Boston Celtics. It's a honor, not an insult. Maybe Nikki S. doesn't like sports or just doesn't understand that. The images, like all team mascot images, are cartoons or caricatures, which are not always flattering, but look at the look of fierce resolve on the mascot's face shown in the picture. It's meant to be a young Native American who is tough and determined. That's what comes through when I look at it. The little girl in the bottom corner is just plain cute.

    Posted by: Mike | Wednesday, July 28, 2010 at 01:18 PM

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    Posted by:  | 

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    The comments on this are getting really nasty. It would be great if more people would chime-in so that the extremists don't think they are correct.

    Posted via email from Doug's posterous

    8 comments: